Monday, August 30, 2010

Strategy Reflection1

Justin Baisden


Strategy Reflection

Marzano Chapter 8

Strategy: Setting Objectives and Providing Feedback



Summary:

Chapter 8 of the Marzano text discusses the importance of setting goals and providing feedback. Marzano explains the importance of goals and states that inctructional goals should narrow what a student focuses on, they should not be too specific, and students should be encouraged to personalize the goals set by the teacher. Robert Mager went as far as to say that instructional goals are defined by three characteristics which are performace, conditions, and criterion. All classroom goals need to be specific the way Mager explained but also flexible in nature. Goals can also be contracted with the student that they will meet certain instructional goals in the class. A very common strategy for teachers is providing students with proper feedback. Marzano says that feedback should be corrective in nature, timely, and specific to criterion. Marzano also states that students can effectively provide some of their own feedback. Feedback needs to be based on the student’s knowledge and skill and not on a percentage score. Student led feedback in which student’s provide feedback for each other by reviewing each other’s assignments is also a way of students to get good fresh ideas about certain topics.



Connection of reading to another reading in class:

In Marzano’s The Art and Science of Teaching he elaborates on what was talked about in chapter nine of Classroom Instruction that Works. The chapter starts off discussing ways of setting those important goals for your students. The Art shows different theories and research that proves the effectiveness of goals setting for students. Marzano goes on to say that students can do more than personalize their own learning goals. Marzano discusses in this book that students can go as far as to identify their own learning goals. The author lets us know in this second reading that it is also important for teachers to make rubrics for the learning goals so a student has a better idea about what is expected of them in the classroom. The author also states that goal setting and feedback need to work together. The goal helps the student see what they are working towards in the classroom but the feedback is necessary to keep a student on the right path when it comes to meeting that goal.



Application of reading to my own teaching interests

I like Marzano’s theories on goals and feedback. I believe the key to a student’s success in the classroom can be through good communication about his/her progress during the semester. Many teacher’s take up student’s work and never lets him/her know how they are doing. This means the student does not know if they are on the right path or if they might need to change direction a little bit. Teachers that do hand back work with just a percentage grade on it may stifle a student and make them feel helpless if they receive a bad grade and can not see what they done wrong or how they might improve. Setting goals provides students with that important direction in their studies and providing feedback insures that with the proper effort any student can attain those goals. Rubrics are a very important tool in a social studies classroom when it comes to projects and different assignments that students will be working on and by setting goals for the students and providing an effective rubric for that goal students may be able to gain a lot more from a social studies classroom.

2 comments:

  1. Good post. Knowledgable and informative. I especially like your emphasis on rubrics to keep a constructive framework to student choice. Personally, the student empowerment scene is rather new to me and I've been thinking of ways to do so without total anarchy of the real classroom breaking out (sometimes scholarly theory fails to meet practical day to day practice). However, rubrics would work well and as a fellow social studies major I like the idea. In criticism of your post, for the sake of being critical, you talk about personalization a bit but you don't go further to discuss a student's built in world view and how that can affect learning. I know it's not in the chapter and you were focused on other comparable readings but since you mentioned it I believe some insight into that realm would have bettered the post.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like your thoughts on the importance of getting feedback to students regarding their progress. Good communication is a vital part of the learning process. I feel that this aspect of teaching may get skipped over from time to time because of the amount of time and effort it requires. A teacher who does make a point to regularly communicate with students most likely genuinely cares about making sure each child reaches his/her potential.

    ReplyDelete