Monday, September 13, 2010

comparing and contrasting

Justin Baisden


9-13-2010

CI415



Summary:

Chapter 8 of Marzano’s text focuses on identifying similarities and differences. The section lets us know as future teachers that there are more than a handful of ways to accomplish this goal. The author draws four generalizations from the research in this area of study. First the author states that presenting students with explicit guidance in identification of similarities and differences enhances student understanding. Next asking students to independently identify similarities and differences enhance students’ understanding of knowledge and the ability to use it. Using graphic organizers helps students better understand this knowledge. Identification can happen in many different ways. Two different graphic organizers students can use are the vinn diagram and the comparison matrix. The main difference between the two is that the comparison matrix requires more strict guidelines. The classifications can be decided on by the teacher or the students or possibly both. Metaphors and analogies are also another good way of comparing and contrasting. There are also various graphic organizers that may be used for students when using these metaphors and analogies. What organizer that works best simply depends on the situation and the teacher’s preference because all are effective in different ways. The organizers are just used to better represent the material to students.



Connection of reading to another reading in class:

In Chapter 3 of The Art and Science of Teaching Marzano again mentions the importance of compare and contrasting in the classroom. Marzano again lists the different ways to compare and contrast and gives a brief definition of each one. The text states that a teacher should provide students with work that requires them to examine the similarities and differences. The text also shows a graphic organizer which is much like a more complex version of a vinn diagram but it gives the students more opportunities for more elaborate connections. When doing this the teacher should help the students see their errors in the way they think. Teachers should also provide students with time to practice this new way of thinking. Marzano states that these practice sessions should be very structured at first and as time goes on they should become less structured so students can grow with these skills in differentiation. This is the point where they can become more creative and use those higher levels of DOK.



Application of reading to my own teaching interests:

I love the use of comparing and contrasting in a classroom although I believe Marzano done a good job of over complicating a practice that is very simple to use. In a social studies classroom comparing and contrasting is very useful when comparing time periods or conflicts. This practice is also good when trying to compare and contrast different societies. Students could use a double bubble to compare and contrast the Mayans and the Incas. I believe this helps show students that all groups of people have their differences but also helps show the common bonds we have with each other that makes us productive members of societies. This is also very good for political debates. If I want to have a debate on a certain topic or political candidate we can put a diagram on the board and start listing things that these topics have in common and in what ways they are different and this helps the students decide which side they are really on.

1 comment:

  1. I really like what you said about comparing and contrasting different cultures. Using a venn diagram would make it very easy to show students not only the differences in cultures, but how they are similar. It would also be a perfect strategy to use for elections to see where candidates stand on what issues. Great ideas!

    ReplyDelete